The Budget Fashionista

Ok, so I picked up a tube of Maybelline mascara last week and had a horrible allergic reaction.  I have never had a reaction like that before, but decided to stick with mascara for sensitive eyes from now on. 

I picked up a tube of Almay but wanted to know if anyone had any other recommendations.

Have you tried neutrogena? physicans forumula? other?  I like Clinique but it is a bit $$$.

I just have had my eyes get really irritated when I used their mascara before so I am looking for a mascara with more natural ingredients

I am under the impression that Almay is working for you, so that means you need not go for prescriptive mascaras. But i am just going to tell you two mascaras which one of my friends is using and that are Loreal lash out, Cover girl lash exact. She used Cover for quite sometime and had no complaints while she was using them but then she switched on to Loreal and its far more better for her.  But i would rather suggest that you first become aware of the ingredient that causes you itching and then perhaps you will be in a better position to choose the best for you.