Perhaps your mom is a dentist, and you appreciate dental floss and mini-mouthwashes with fluoride. Or perhaps your mom isn’t a dentist, and you appreciate drugstore brand candy that looks Christmas-y but tastes eerily familiar to cough medicine.

We get it. Stocking stuffers = conceptually cute, but usually sucky in reality. We’re changing that this holiday season, so get excited for the goodies: small enough to fit inside those oversized socks, but not completely useless. Here’s the lowdown on what to get who.

Stuff Socks with these Awesome Gift Ideas

Picture 4 of 12

Fashion forward sister:

Deco Daze Faux Lashes, $8.00 from Sephora
She's going to want to stand out when she's trying to sneak in a kiss with the mysterious stud muffin at the hot New Year's Party she's attending. Why not give her lashes an extra boost and sparkle?